Implementing the Logical Structure of Stoic Ethics in the First Five Chapters of Epictetus' Enchiridion

 

Implementing the Logical Structure of Stoic Ethics Found in the First Five Chapters of Epictetus' Enchiridion

The Logical Structure of Stoic Ethics 

1. Human flourishing consists in virtue and joy

2. Virtue is in our control

3. Joy is in our control

4. External things are not in our control

5. Virtue is good

6. Vice is evil

7. External things are not good

8. External things are not evil

9. Emotions occur if and only if we believe external things have value

10. External things have no value

11. Without believing external things have value, there are no emotions

12. Virtue leads to not believing external things have value

13. Joy leads to not believing external things have value

14. Therefore, human flourishing consists in not believing external things have value and virtue

Claude:

# The Integrated Stoic Practice of Making Correct Use of Impressions 

Here's the integrated practice with explicit connections to the logical ethical principles: 

## Preparatory Understanding

- Recognize that human flourishing consists in virtue and joy *(Principle 1)*⁸ 

1. Human flourishing consists in virtue and joy 

- Understand that virtue and joy are within your control *(Principles 2 & 3)* 

2. Virtue is in our control

3. Joy is in our controlĺ 

- Accept that external things are neither good nor evil in themselves *(Principles 7 & 8)* 

7. External things are not good

8. External things are not evil

## The Integrated Practice 

1. **Encounter an Impression**

   - When faced with any situation, person, or object, pause and recognize: "This is an impression"

   - *This connects to Principle 9: emotions occur if and only if we believe external things have value* 

9. Emotions occur if and only if we believe external things have value

2. **Apply the Dichotomy of Control** [E.1]

   - Ask: "Is this within my control or outside my control?" *(Addresses Principles 2, 3, & 4)* 

2. Virtue is in our control

3. Joy is in our control

4. External things are not in our control 

   - Classify clearly: opinions, judgments, and choices (internal) vs. events, others' actions, and material things (external)

   - *This reinforces Principle 4: external things are not in our control* 

4. External things are not in our control 

Enchiridion 1 and the Logical Structure of Stoic Ethics

3. **Examine Your Judgments** [E.5]

   - Recognize that your disturbance comes not from the thing itself but from your judgment about it

   - Say to yourself: "It is my judgment about this that disturbs me, not the thing itself"

   - *This applies Principle 10 external things have no value* 

10. External things have no value 

   - Question: "Am I assigning value to an external thing that has no intrinsic value?" *(Directly addresses Principle 9)* 

9. Emotions occur if and only if we believe external things have value 

Enchiridion 5 and the Logical Structure of Stoic Ethics

4. **Visualize and Prepare** [E4]

   - Before engaging, remind yourself of the true nature of what you're about to encounter

   - Mentally rehearse potential challenges and your equanimous response

   - *This strengthens Principle 11: without believing external things have value, there are no emotions* 

11. Without believing external things have value, there are no emotions 

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/16DYn3nbKD/

5. **Suspend and Redirect** [E.2]

   - Suspend immediate desire or aversion toward externals

   - Direct desire only toward virtue and proper judgment *(Applying Principle 5: virtue is good)* 

5. Virtue is good 

   - Apply aversion only to false judgments *(Applying Principle 6: vice is evil)* 

6. Vice is evil 

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/15uEPHEUrQ/

6. **Reaffirm True Value** [E.3]

   - Remind yourself: "Virtue alone is good, vice alone is evil, all else is indifferent" *(Directly stating Principles 5, 6, 7, & 8)* 

5. Virtue is good

6. Vice is evil

7. External things are not good

8. External things are not evil 

   - For valued possessions, rehearse their potential loss with equanimity 

   - *This practice embodies Principles 12 & 13: virtue and joy lead to not believing external things have value* 

12. Virtue leads to not believing external things have value

13. Joy leads to not believing external things have value 

Through consistent application of this practice, you align yourself with the ultimate Stoic conclusion *(Principle 14)*: human flourishing consists in not believing external things have value and in pursuing virtue. 

14. Therefore, human flourishing consists in not believing external things have value and virtue 

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1DfbwQ4812/