Stoic News

By Dave Kelly

Friday, August 08, 2025

Step 5: Change Your Judgments in Real-Time

Step 5: Change Your Judgments in Real-Time

Complete Sterling Logical Language (SLL) System v. 16


## Current State:

- **Axiom**: Only virtue is good, only vice is evil

- **Rule**: Don't desire externals  

- **Control Test**: "Is this in my control or not?"

- **Precision**: You control beliefs, judgments, choices

- **Emotion Connection**: Emotions come from your value judgments


## Step 5: The Judgment Replacement Protocol


**THE METHOD**: When you catch a false judgment, immediately replace it with the true one.


## The 3-Step Real-Time Process:


### 1. CATCH the False Judgment

- Feel an unwanted emotion

- Ask: "What am I judging as good or bad right now?"

- Identify the external thing you're valuing


### 2. RECOGNIZE It's False

- Ask: "Is this actually virtue or vice?"

- If it's external (not virtue/vice), the judgment is false

- Remind yourself: "Only virtue is good, only vice is evil"


### 3. REPLACE with True Judgment

- **Instead of**: "This traffic is bad"

- **Say**: "This traffic is neither good nor bad - it's indifferent"

- **Instead of**: "Getting this job would be good"

- **Say**: "Getting this job is indifferent - only my virtuous response matters"


## Live Examples:


**Traffic Jam Scenario:**

- CATCH: "I'm judging this delay as bad"

- RECOGNIZE: "Delay isn't virtue or vice - judgment is false"

- REPLACE: "This delay is indifferent. My patient response could be virtuous."


**Job Rejection Scenario:**

- CATCH: "I'm judging this rejection as terrible"

- RECOGNIZE: "Job outcomes aren't virtue or vice - judgment is false"  

- REPLACE: "This rejection is indifferent. How I handle it shows my character."


**Relationship Conflict:**

- CATCH: "I'm judging their behavior as bad for me"

- RECOGNIZE: "Their behavior isn't virtue or vice for me - judgment is false"

- REPLACE: "Their behavior is indifferent to my wellbeing. My response is what matters."


## What Happens:


- **Immediate emotional relief** (false judgments cause emotional disturbance)

- **Clearer thinking** (not clouded by emotional reactivity)

- **Better decisions** (focused on what you can actually control)

- **Character development** (practicing virtue in real situations)


## The Advanced Move:


Once you get good at this, you can **prevent** false judgments before they form by habitually asking "Is this virtue, vice, or indifferent?" about everything that happens.


## What This Completes:


**You now have a complete operating system:**

1. Know what's actually good (virtue only)

2. Know what you control (judgments/beliefs/choices)

3. Know what causes emotions (value judgments)

4. Know how to change emotions (change judgments)

5. Know how to do it in real-time (the 3-step protocol)


**This is functional Stoicism. Everything else is elaboration.**

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home