The Household Discharged — A Novel
The Household Discharged — A Novel
Companion novel to The Professor’s House (Cather, 1925), composed under the Narrative Composition Protocol (NCP v0.4). Commitment slate: C1 Carry, C2 Carry (load-bearing), C3 Leave Non-Operative, C4 Non-Operative by standing ruling, C5 Divergently Affirms, C6 Carry (resolved). Instrument architecture and analysis: Dave Kelly. Prose rendering: Claude (Anthropic). 2026.
Chapter I
The removal was finished by noon, and Dr. Aldous Furnival stood alone in the emptied house where he had lived since his marriage, and where he had raised two daughters and written the seven volumes of his History of the Roman Settlements in Britain.
It was not a handsome house, and had never pretended to be one: narrow-fronted, three storeys, the stair treads worn to a shine down the middle and hollow at the edges where thirty years of feet had climbed them. He had complained of the draught under the study door every winter of his tenancy, and had never mended it, there being always some more urgent thing to mend. He walked the bare rooms this last morning cataloguing, out of habit rather than sentiment, the inconveniences he had tolerated: the window that would not latch, the grate that smoked in an east wind, the low beam in the passage that had cracked his skull twice in the first year and had thereafter been ducked for automatically, without his ever quite deciding to duck.
His wife had gone ahead to the new house with the last of the boxes. It stood a mile off, on ground he had bought with the proceeds of the seventh volume — a square, correct, modern house, with a study fitted for him that had bookshelves to the ceiling and a desk his daughter Honor had chosen herself, and not one thing in it that had been chosen by accident or worn smooth by use. He had walked through it twice and found nothing to object to, which he counted, privately, a kind of failure in the house.
At the top of the old stair, under the slope of the roof, was the room that had actually been his study, whatever the ground-floor room with the good shelves had been called. It was small, and cold in winter, and lit by a single casement that swung out on a hook, and he had written every word of the seven volumes in it, at a table with one leaf permanently propped, because he had never got round to mending that either.
He had arranged with his landlord, an unhurried Wiltshire man named Barrow, to keep the room for another quarter, on the pretext of finishing a piece of writing that did not, strictly, exist yet. What existed was a promise, made to himself some months before and not yet redeemed, to set in order the papers of Anthony Merefield.
Merefield had been dead nine years. He had been, in the whole of Furnival’s teaching life, the one pupil whose mind had answered to instruction the way a struck bell answers — not obedient exactly, but resonant, giving back more than had gone in. He had gone up to Furnival’s college a farrier’s son from the Welsh border, unable at first to construct a proper Latin period, and had left it four years later able to argue Furnival himself into a corner on the dating of the Antonine reoccupation, which no other pupil in twenty years had managed. He had died at Loos, in the third week, of a wound that need not have killed a man attended sooner.
What he had left behind him, besides the memory, was a fortune. In the last year before the war he had made, almost as a diversion from his proper studies, an improvement to the surveying instruments used in coal prospecting — a correction to an error in the levelling apparatus that the whole trade had been living with for a generation without troubling to fix. He had patented it, more from tidiness than ambition, and gone to France, and the patent had gone on quietly making money without him, into an estate that passed, on his death, to the young woman he had been engaged to marry.
That young woman was now Furnival’s own daughter Rosalind, married these four years to Edmund Ancroft, a man of considerable warmth, considerable energy, and — Furnival privately thought, though he had never once said so to Rosalind — considerable want of the one thing that could not be purchased with Merefield’s money, which was any idea of what Merefield’s money was for.
The new house they had all just moved into stood on the strength of Furnival’s own royalties, not Merefield’s fortune; that distinction he had insisted upon, at some cost to comfort, and meant to go on insisting upon. But it was Ancroft’s money, freely and constantly offered and as constantly declined, that had furnished half the arguments of the last four years, and it was Ancroft’s habit of naming things after Merefield — a wing of the new country place the young couple were building was to be called, Furnival had learned only the week before, “Merefield Court” — that had produced the one real quarrel of his daughter’s married life, conducted, as all their quarrels were, in tones of perfect civility across a dinner table.
“You dislike it,” his wife had said to him afterward, not as a question.
“I dislike the name attached to a great deal of Norwegian pine and imported ironwork,” he had answered. “Anthony never saw a house he thought worth building. He’d have laughed at it and then felt ashamed of laughing, and gone on liking Edmund anyway, because that was his way with people who meant well and understood nothing.”
“You might allow that Edmund means well.”
“I allow it freely. I only decline to allow that meaning well is the same accomplishment as understanding.”
He had gone up to the old house the next morning, as he did most mornings that were not lecture mornings, and had sat some hours at the propped table doing nothing that could be called work, turning over in his mind — not for the first time, but with a persistence that had lately begun to trouble him a little, as a symptom troubles a man who does not yet want to name it an illness — the question of what, exactly, he owed to the memory of a pupil nine years dead, and what that owing required of him now that the pupil’s fortune had passed into hands that loved without understanding, and his own hands held nothing of Merefield’s but a locked deed-box of papers, a battered theodolite case, and a promise not yet kept.
Chapter II
That evening he dined at the new house, where his younger daughter Honor and her husband, a journalist named Philip Rede, were also dining, together with a Belgian mining engineer named Vandaele whom Ancroft had met on the Antwerp exchange and had, in his usual way, invited home before either of them had finished being introduced.
“You’ll forgive the disorder, Monsieur Vandaele,” Rosalind said, though there was no disorder to forgive; the new house had arranged itself into perfect order within a week, which was itself the thing Furnival found faintly disorderly. “We have only just come in.”
“It is a very fine house,” said Vandaele, who had the tact of a man accustomed to being agreeable in a third language. “Mr. Ancroft tells me it was built almost entirely from the proceeds of an invention. That is a romantic thing, in England. On the Continent we are less romantic about levelling instruments.”
“The Outland — I mean the Merefield principle,” Ancroft corrected himself, with a small laugh at his own slip that did not quite conceal how often he made it, “has paid for a good deal more than the house, I promise you. Rosalind’s father won’t take a penny of it himself, which I call very hard on us, since it leaves us looking a great deal more grasping than we are.”
“My father-in-law,” said Rosalind, with the particular brightness she used when she meant to close a subject before it opened further, “believes that gratitude is a private matter and should not be allowed near a chequebook.”
“I believe no such general thing,” Furnival said. “I believe that my gratitude to Anthony Merefield is a private matter, and that a chequebook is a very poor vessel for carrying it. That is a narrower claim than the one you’ve made on my behalf, and I’d be obliged if you’d let me make my own claims in future.”
It was said mildly enough, but Rede — who wrote a column three times a week under the byline “The Onlooker,” full of exactly the kind of florid good cheer his father-in-law privately despised, and who therefore understood better than anyone at the table what it cost the Professor to sound mild while saying something ungentle — glanced up from his soup with the flicker of a man recognizing a blow landed cleanly.
“What was he like, sir?” Vandaele asked, into the small silence. “Merefield. I confess I know him only as a correction to an error in a levelling scale, which is not much to know a man by.”
Furnival considered the question with more seriousness than the dinner table generally received.
“He noticed things other men had stopped noticing because they’d got used to them,” he said at last. “Most of us stop noticing an error once we’ve learned to correct for it by habit. Anthony was constitutionally unable to do that. He’d correct for a fault a hundred times and be irritated by it the hundred-and-first, as though it were the first time he’d met it. It made him a considerable nuisance as an undergraduate and a very great engineer, and I don’t imagine those were two different qualities in him. I imagine they were one.”
“And he left you nothing of the fortune,” Vandaele said, not quite as a question.
“He left me nothing of the fortune because there was nothing between us that money could have been payment for. I taught him what I knew because he wanted it faster than I could give it, which is the only reason worth teaching anyone anything. If I’d been paid for that, or if I let myself be paid for it now, at one remove, through my daughter’s husband’s generosity —” he stopped himself, aware that he had gone further than the table wanted, and finished more quietly — “it would stop being what it was, and become something else. I’m too old to want the something else.”
Honor, who alone among the four young people at table had actually known Merefield — she had been sixteen when he went to France, and had corresponded with him twice a week for the eleven months he was gone, letters her father had never read and never asked to read — said nothing at all, but reached for her wine glass and did not drink from it, only held it, turning the stem a little, until the subject had safely passed.
Later, when the Vandaeles and Redes had gone and Rosalind had gone up, Ancroft found Furnival alone in the smoking-room and stood a moment in the doorway before coming in, in the manner of a man who has decided to say a difficult thing and is giving himself one last chance to change his mind.
“I know you think me a fool about the name of the place,” he said. “Merefield Court. Rosalind’s told me you dislike it.”
“I dislike it less than I dislike being managed into a dispute about it at my own dinner table,” Furnival said, not unkindly. “You may call the house what you please, Edmund. It’s yours to name.”
“That’s not quite an absolution, sir, if you don’t mind my saying so.”
Furnival looked at him — really looked, for perhaps the first time that evening — and found, not for the first time either, that he could not dislike the man, however much he wished the clarity of being able to.
“No,” he agreed. “It isn’t. I don’t think I have one to give you. I think you loved a story about Anthony Merefield that Rosalind told you, and never met the man the story was about, and there is no absolution I can hand you for that, because it isn’t a fault. It’s only a distance. Some distances don’t close.”
Ancroft, to his credit, did not attempt to close it there and then, but only nodded, and said good night, and left the Professor alone with a dead fire and the particular species of tiredness that comes from having, for once, said exactly what one meant.
Chapter III
Furnival woke the next morning with the wish that he might be carried, mattress and all, back to the old house; but it was Sunday, and on Sundays his wife always breakfasted with him, wherever he happened to be sleeping. There was no avoiding it.
“Good morning, Aldous,” Cordelia said, from behind the coffee things. “I hope you slept.”
“Very well, thank you. And you?”
“I slept on a clear conscience.” She said it lightly, but her eyes did not quite match the lightness. “You were rather hard on Edmund last night.”
“I was rather honest with Edmund last night, which he is not accustomed to from anyone but you, and which he took, I thought, with more grace than either of us gave him credit for.”
“You mistake his good manners for understanding. He went up to bed believing himself forgiven.”
“I told him plainly he wasn’t. I don’t know what more honesty he could reasonably ask of me.”
Cordelia poured his coffee without answering at once. She was a fair woman, going a little grey now at the temple in a way that suited her better than it had any right to, and she had the particular gift — which Furnival had loved in her for thirty years and had never once managed to imitate — of knowing exactly what a room required of her, and supplying it, while he stood at the edge of every room he entered wondering what was required and generally deciding, too late, that it was probably the opposite of whatever he had just said.
“When did it begin, do you suppose,” she said, “this notion that a man mustn’t say when he’s pleased with his own house, or his own success, without it being thought vulgar? You didn’t use to mind saying so.”
“I minded it well enough. I only used to be too young to have anything worth being proud of, which simplified the question considerably.”
“That’s not what I asked.”
“No,” he agreed, “it isn’t,” and did not answer it, and she let him not answer it, in the manner of two people who have long ago agreed which doors in a marriage are worth opening and which are better left shut, out of a kind of tact that had nothing to do with cowardice and everything to do with thirty years’ practice.
He had met her in Rome, when he was twenty-six and reading for his fellowship, and she had been the ward of an English family wintering there for her health, which had never been robust and had improved, by her own account, the moment she left England and had declined steadily ever since her return to it. She had not then, and did not now, have what anyone could honestly call a scholar’s mind; what she had was an unerring instinct for what was genuine in a person and what was performance, an instinct she had exercised on his behalf for three decades with a reliability his own judgment, for all its training, had never matched. He had taken the Hamilton chair — no, not Hamilton, he corrected himself out of an old habit of precision even in his own thoughts, the chair at Aldbury — because he had to marry at once and it was the first thing offered, and had thrown himself upon her for the greater part of his intellectual companionship for the better part of thirty years, there being no one else at Aldbury of any real subtlety of mind, save one physicist named Corbould, a narrow and unwell man whose whole conversation ran to the extent of interstellar space and nothing else.
There had been no one to make Cordelia jealous, in all that time, until Anthony Merefield.
He did not raise it now; there was no need. She had been jealous of the boy in the plain, unfashionable way a woman is jealous of anyone who has taken some portion of her husband’s attention that she had believed, without ever quite counting it, to be entirely hers, and she had never forgiven Merefield for it, not even in death, not even now that his memory sat between them at every dinner table like an uninvited guest neither of them could ask to leave.
“You didn’t answer me properly,” she said again, rising, “but I’ll let it go. You have your lecture.”
He walked across the park afterward, on his way to the old house, and there met, taking his customary Sunday turn in a fresh grey suit and a hat of unusual excellence, his colleague and rival of twenty years, Dr. Osric Pell.
“Good morning, Pell. The plane trees are finally becoming trees, don’t you think? They’ve changed a great deal since we first came here.”
“Good morning, Furnival. I can’t say I’ve given the trees much thought.”
“There’ve been a great many changes,” Furnival persisted, though he knew already, from twenty years’ experience, that nothing would come of it, “and not all of them for the better. You don’t find the students of a poorer quality than they were, taken as a whole?”
“I couldn’t say I’ve noticed it.”
They had come to the college young men together, fighting for their places, and were neither of them young any longer, and would neither of them, probably, ever hold a better position than the one he presently held; and it struck Furnival, not for the first time, that it was a very great waste of a life to have spent twenty years of it maintaining a grievance against a man who had, when all the accounts were finally totted up, been beaten quite as thoroughly as he had.
Chapter IV
On the Monday following, Furnival lay on the box-couch in the old study, tired from a day of lectures and committee, when he heard a light step on the stair and his elder daughter’s voice: “May I disturb you, Papa?”
“Never a disturbance, my dear. Sit down, if you can find where.”
Rosalind glanced about the cramped little room — the propped table, the two dressmaker’s forms in the corner that Mercy Coles left there between her visits, the general shabbiness of a place that had never once been furnished for show — and something in her look told him plainly what she had come to say before she said it.
“Edmund and I have talked it over a great deal,” she began, “and we do wish you’d let us build you a proper study at the new house. Something worthy of the work you do. You needn’t trouble yourself with any of it — I have such good notions already.”
“It’s very good of you to think of it, Rosie. But leave it as a notion — it’s better so. I’ll go on plodding here a while yet. A work-room ought to be like an old boot; no matter how disreputable, it answers better than a new one.”
“That’s not really what I came to say.” She traced the worn edge of the matting with the toe of her shoe. “It’s a harder thing than the study. You know Edmund and I have talked about it often. We don’t feel it’s right that we should have the whole benefit of Anthony’s discovery and you none of it. We want to settle an income on you, so you needn’t lecture at all, and could give the whole of your time to writing.”
He rose at once, with the quick, nervous motion that overtook him whenever he was moved more than he wished to show, and went to the window and stood with his back to her a moment before turning round.
“I couldn’t possibly take a penny of it, Rosalind, and I’d be obliged if we needn’t go over the ground again. It isn’t that I doubt your motives, or Edmund’s — they do you both credit. It’s that there was nothing between Anthony and me that money could ever have been payment for, and I won’t have it made so now, at one remove, through you. It would turn the one clean thing left to me into something else. I’m too old to want the something else.”
“But he owed you so much, Papa. He said so himself, more than once.”
“He owed me nothing beyond what I owed him, which was the plain pleasure of teaching a mind worth teaching. In a lifetime of lecturing, I’ve met one mind of that quality. If that had been all I got from thirty years at a desk, I’d not count the years wasted.”
She went away not entirely persuaded, as he had known she would not be, and after she had gone he lay a long while on the couch without lighting his pipe, thinking that he understood his elder daughter a good deal less than he understood the younger, and had understood her a good deal less, if he were honest, since the day of her engagement.
Chapter V
It was a bright, blowing Saturday in early autumn when Philip Rede came out to the old house to fetch his father-in-law for a walk along the river, having cut his own work for the afternoon on the strength of the fine weather.
“You’ll forgive me saying, sir,” Rede said, as they came down to the towpath, “that I overheard something of Edmund’s scheme, about the income. Honor told me. I hope you sent it off with a flea in its ear.”
“I sent it off as gently as I could manage, which I’m not sure was gently at all.”
“Good. I can’t abide the way he goes about naming things after Merefield, as though the man were a public monument rather than somebody I actually knew. We were at Balliol together, you know — Anthony and I — before he ever crossed your threshold. Edmund never so much as shook his hand.”
“I know it. I confess it’s one of the things I find hardest to forgive Edmund, though I know perfectly well there’s nothing to forgive — a man can’t be blamed for arriving too late to know someone.”
“He might at least arrive quietly.”
Furnival laughed, the first unguarded laugh he had managed in some days. “You must forgive me if I don’t encourage you in that particular resentment, Philip, tempting as it is. Edmund is a great deal more generous than I am, and my private preferences would be quite unintelligible to him if I tried to explain them. I can hardly ask you to carry a grudge I won’t voice myself.”
They walked some way in silence after that, Rede evidently turning something over, his usual restless good humour gone quiet.
“I sometimes think,” he said at last, “that I write my column three days a week telling the whole country to keep its pecker up, and I haven’t the first notion any longer why anyone ought to. It sells a great many papers. I don’t know that it does anything else.”
“It keeps you and Honor housed and fed, which is not nothing.”
“No. It’s not nothing.” He said it without conviction, and threw a stone into the current, and they walked on.
Chapter VI
Furnival came home early one afternoon in October and, crossing the lawn toward the French windows, paused a moment before going in, arrested by the scene within: the drawing-room full of late roses and michaelmas daisies, the low sun lying in bright pools on the carpet, Cordelia and Ancroft bent together over a small lacquered box at the tea-table.
“They are very fine, Edmund,” Cordelia was saying, turning a string of pearls in the light, “but they seem a little beyond your present scale. You aren’t, after all, outrageously rich.”
“At home, Dearest, at our own table — what does scale matter? I’ve never given her jewels before. I’ve waited on purpose to give her these.”
Furnival came in over the sill. “That is always the cue for the husband’s entrance, is it not? And what is this, Edmund?”
Ancroft brought him his tea, lingering by the chair with the particular eagerness that never failed to disarm the Professor a little, however much he braced against it. “A secret from Rosalind, sir, until her birthday. We’re to keep it a fortnight yet.”
“You’re a generous man, Edmund. I wish I found it easier to say so without qualification.”
“I’d rather have the qualification honestly given than the compliment dressed up,” Ancroft said, with more shrewdness than Furnival generally credited him, and for a moment the Professor felt the small, familiar shame of having underestimated a man out of nothing more respectable than an old grief.
Chapter VII
Early in November, on a day of the first hard frost, Honor rang her father at the college and asked him to call at the house on his way home, to help her choose some furs. When he came up the path he found Ancroft’s car standing at the kerb, and Rosalind coming down the steps alone, a coat of soft dove-grey fur disguising, not unbecomingly, the slight stoop he had always privately regretted in her.
“That’s new, Rosie, and very fine. Edmund’s choosing, I suppose?”
“Of course. He chooses everything for me now.” She said it with a pride that struck him, not for the first time, as very slightly too bright, as though she were reassuring herself as much as him.
He let her go, and made a long business of the door-scraper before he knocked, aware that Honor was watching him from behind the curtain. She let him in pale and silent, and when at last he opened the boxes of furs she had bought and held a stole up to show her, she broke down entirely.
“It’s no use today, Papa. I don’t want any of it, really. She spoils everything for me, and I can’t help minding, and I hate myself for minding.”
“You mustn’t let yourself be envious, Honor. It eats a person from within — I’ve watched it do it.”
“I can’t help it. When we were girls she was a kind of ideal to me — whatever she thought, settled the matter for me too. But she’s changed. She’s become Edmund, or worse than Edmund. Why didn’t you and Dr. Corbould do something with Anthony’s patent yourselves, before it fell into hands like that?”
“Whatever came of it was hers by his own will, Honor. There was no other course open to any of us.”
“I don’t want her money,” Honor said fiercely, throwing up her head.
“Nor do I, and we mustn’t behave as though we did, either of us, or we’ll make ourselves very unhappy over a thing not worth the unhappiness.”
He walked home through the early dark with a heavy step, thinking that of his two daughters it was Honor who had needed his protection from the first, and Honor whom he understood, and Honor who alone among them had kept faith, in her own silent way, with what Anthony Merefield had actually been, rather than with what his money had since become.
Chapter VIII
At the end of term Furnival went up to London with Rosalind, to help her choose furnishings for the new country house. He had wanted badly to stay at home and rest — the college work seemed to take more out of him that year than it ever had before — but Rosalind had set her mind on it, and Cordelia told him plainly he couldn’t refuse. A dealer in Bond Street had brought over a quantity of old Spanish furniture, and on such matters nobody’s judgment was better than his.
Edmund came up with them as far as the station, on his way to join a brother in the shipping trade for a family gathering, and made such a business of his leave-taking, waving his hat from the platform of the boat train until it was quite out of sight, that Furnival was startled to feel, once he had gone, a distinct and unwelcome sense of loss. He had so often complained that there was too much of Edmund in his life.
“We must be industrious, Rosie,” he said, taking her arm as they turned from the rails. “He expects wonders of us.”
The week that followed was, as he confessed to Cordelia on his return, “rather an orgy of acquisition.” Rosalind had, it turned out, a faultless purchasing manner — cool, swift, undeceived by anything second-rate — and he found himself, by the fourth day, paying for a good deal more of it than either of them had planned, out of a stubbornness he recognised even as he indulged it: any suggestion that Rosalind might settle his account would have been gracefully made and firmly declined, and he preferred the expense to the alternative.
They dined one evening at the opera with tickets Edmund had left standing, and in the darkness between the acts Cordelia — who had come up to join them for the last two days — leaned toward him with a softness in her face he had not seen in some years.
“It was a mistake, Aldous,” she said, “our having a family and writing histories and growing middle-aged. We ought to have been picturesquely shipwrecked together, when we were young.”
“How often I’ve thought it myself,” she added, before he could answer, and there was something in her voice — an old grief, healed over but never quite gone — that told him plainly the children had not been the whole of what had come between them, all those years ago, and he had never once, until that moment, thought to ask what the rest of it might have been.
They returned to Aldbury in bitter weather, and within the week Cordelia was pressing him, as she pressed him every winter, not to go on with the old house and its wretched little stove.
“It isn’t safe, Aldous, with the window kept open as you keep it. A gust could put it out and you’d never notice till you were half poisoned.”
“I’ve had headaches from it before and lived to tell of them.”
“And isn’t it a foolish extravagance, paying rent on an entire house to sit in one uncomfortable room of it?”
“It is almost my only extravagance,” he said, with more heat than the remark warranted, and went out to put on his overshoes, leaving her to reflect, not for the first time that winter, how irritable he had lately become.
Chapter IX
For Christmas Day the weather turned mild, and Furnival had the whole of it to himself in the old house, Cordelia having packed him sandwiches so he needn’t come back for lunch. He kept a little port in the chest under the dressmaker’s forms, brought back from a Sabbatical in Lisbon years before, and meant to make a quiet holiday of the papers he had promised himself he would finally set in order.
He met Mercy Coles crossing the park on her way back from church, stiff and neat in her black Sunday coat.
“Still going to the old house, Doctor Furnival? It doesn’t seem right, on Christmas Day.”
“It isn’t the same without you there to scold me for the smoke, Mercy. Won’t you come dress my two ladies in the corner one of these evenings, as a surprise? They’ve had no new toilette in months.”
She laughed, in the guarded way she always laughed at him, half certain he oughtn’t to be encouraged. “You’re a strange man for a scholar, Doctor. If anyone else in this parish said the things you say to your classes, I’d have him spoken to.”
“And how do you come to hear what I say to my classes, may I ask?”
“They repeat it, of course, when you go on about the Church the way you do.”
“I don’t believe I ever do.”
“They take it that way, whatever you believe. You ought to be more careful, clever as you are.”
He walked beside her a little way with the loose, unoccupied stride he kept for Sundays. “Tell me something, Mercy — that verse in the service, about the Tower of Ivory. Is that out of the Magnificat?”
She stopped and looked at him with real astonishment. “Did you have no religious instruction at all, Doctor?”
“None to speak of. My mother was chapel, and there was no proper church within six miles of the farm, and my father, I believe, forgot his religion somewhere on the crossing from Ireland.”
“That happens, in mixed families.” She said it with the particular gravity she reserved for matters of doctrine, and went on to instruct him, at some length and with evident pleasure in the instructing, on a point of liturgy he had genuinely wanted to know and would, characteristically, have forgotten to ask anyone else.
They parted more cheerful than they had met, and he climbed to his study feeling almost as though she had come up and set the little room to rights, as she used to, in the years when the holidays had still felt like holidays.
Chapter X
It was Honor who brought him the matter of Mercy Coles’s savings, some weeks into the new year, finding him at the propped table one afternoon with his lamp just lit.
“Papa, did you know she’d lost money in that Cornish tin scheme? Five hundred pounds — everything she had, very nearly. She asked Edmund’s advice beforehand and he told her plainly not to touch it, but half her chapel had put money in, and she couldn’t see why it shouldn’t be sound if they thought so.”
“Five hundred pounds.” He set down his pen. “At her rate that’s the best part of two years’ work. We must do something, of course.”
“I went to Rosalind first. She wouldn’t hear of it — says Edmund warned her and she must learn her lesson, or she’ll only do the same again.”
“She can’t refuse, Honor. I’ll speak to her myself.”
“Even if you move her, Mercy won’t take charity outright — you know her pride. When I hinted her customers ought to make it good, she was quite offended, said she wasn’t that sort of needlewoman.”
“Then we must find a way that doesn’t ask her to take it as charity. Philip and I between us can cover the greater part. Leave Rosalind to me — on her own account, if nothing else, she oughtn’t to be let out of a family duty of this kind. It’s petty of her, really, and I think she knows it.”
Honor's eyes went, as they often did in that room, to the foot of the box-couch, where a worn travelling-rug of Merefield's still lay folded, brought back years before from some Alpine excursion and kept, Furnival had always said, because he grew chilly working late.
“He'd have sorted this out in an afternoon, wouldn't he,” she said. “Not the money — the fuss about it. He never let a fuss outlast the thing it was fussing over.”
“No,” Furnival agreed, “he hadn’t the patience for a grievance. It was one of the more enviable things about him.”
She left soon after, and he sat a long while without lighting his pipe, thinking not of the five hundred pounds, which troubled him very little, but of how naturally his younger daughter still reached for Anthony Merefield's name to settle a question, nine years on, as if the boy might yet be consulted on it.
Chapter XI
“I wish you’d keep Edmund from letting his name go up for the Athenaeum just yet,” Furnival said to his wife one evening, taking her hand as he came down dressed for dinner. “It’s not safe. He hasn’t been known long enough among that particular set.”
“You think he’d be blackballed? But the county club took him readily enough —”
“The county club is a large, comfortable affair that wants subscriptions. The Athenaeum crowd is a small, fussy lot, and fussy people take their time.”
“Philip belongs,” Cordelia said, a little rebelliously. “Did he tell you that?”
“He didn’t, and I shan’t say who did. But if you’re tactful, you can spare Edmund the disappointment.”
She closed the book she had not really been reading, and a new light came into her eye that told him, more plainly than any words could have, that she meant to take the matter entirely into her own hands. He turned away to hide his smile. An old pupil, one of the last surviving of what he had privately come to think of as the Merefield years, had told him only that week, laughing, that Philip would very likely blackball Edmund himself if the vote ever came to it — not from any real malice, but from a lingering, boyish soreness that a secret ballot was the one place he could get at his brother-in-law without wounding Honor.
It struck Furnival, watching his wife across the candlelight that evening, how thoroughly she had taken up the game of being courted all over again, now that there were sons-in-law to be managed and charmed rather than a husband grown too settled in his habits to need the managing. She dressed for them, planned for them, entertained on their account with an energy he had not seen in her in a decade. He found he did not resent it — only wondered, watching her, whether she had understood herself so little all those years, or whether it was he who had failed to notice how much of her had simply gone unspent.
Chapter XII
Cordelia and the Ancrofts sailed for the Mediterranean in early May, and Furnival, left to himself, moved his few belongings quietly back to the old house and settled into a bachelor's summer. He knew he ought to be working. The excuse of the garden — such garden as the old house possessed, a strip of gravel and box hedge he had never much troubled over — would not serve much longer to keep him from his desk. But the task waiting there was a difficult one, of the small, stubborn kind at which the hand grows self-conscious.
He had set himself to put Anthony Merefield's field notebooks into order for eventual publication — the record of a single season's survey work on the border country, technical, sparing, almost nothing in it of the boy himself. To mean anything to a reader, it would want a proper introduction: some account of the man behind the measurements. The scientific achievement was easy enough to set down. It was not the whole of the story.
Cordelia had always maintained that Anthony was not, at bottom, quite straightforward, and Furnival supposed this was true only in the sense that the boy had never been entirely consistent. As an investigator he was clear-eyed and exacting; in his personal dealings he was apt to be quixotic, given to an idealised loyalty that sometimes ran ahead of the actual circumstances. He held it a point of honour never to owe a material advantage to a friend, as though affection and advancement were substances that would corrode each other on contact — a scruple Furnival had always traced to the boy's early years, labouring among men for whom disinterested loyalty was the only currency that could not be taken from them.
It was not until Merefield's final undergraduate year that Cordelia's favour toward him had cooled. She had never found fault with the boy while he remained merely a promising pupil; it was only once Furnival began taking him up to the study, making a companion rather than a protégé of him, that she withdrew. She had reasons ready, as she always did, once her fondness had turned: that he was reserved to the point of secrecy about his own history, that there had always been some unaccounted stretch of years before he came up, some early trouble he would not speak of.
The truth of it came out at last on a wet evening that same summer, before the dining-room fire, over a bottle of the Lisbon port and a dish of asparagus Furnival had cooked himself. Merefield had come to dinner as he often did that season, the two of them alone in the house, and had talked more freely than usual, until at last, without any particular prompting, he told the story he had always before kept back — nothing very shocking, nothing even very remarkable in itself, only the sort of thing a young man is tender about until he is old enough not to be.
It is his story, properly, and not Furnival's to tell in Furnival's own words; and since he told it that night much as he had lived it, it is set down here as nearly as it can be, in the way he gave it.
Book Two — Merefield’s Own Account
Chapter I
I had left school at sixteen with nothing behind me but a farrier’s forge and nothing ahead of me that I could then have named, and I took work that first summer with a surveying party laying out boundary lines for a coal company along the Radnorshire hills, because the pay was better than anything else offered to a boy my age, and because I had a knack, even then, for reading a chain and a level that the foreman was quick enough to make use of.
My partner on that survey, and for the two years following, was a man some ten years my senior named Gethin Prosser, a big, easy, careless sort of fellow, quick with his hands and quicker with his tongue, who had drifted into surveying from half a dozen other trades and never seemed to mind which one he was at, so long as there was drink at the end of the week and no one over him he couldn’t talk round. I liked him from the first, and went on liking him a good while after I had learned better.
We were kept on, the two of us, through the autumn and into winter, running lines up a valley the company had bought the mineral rights to but not yet troubled to work, a wild, half-forgotten stretch of hill country where the old drovers’ road still showed in places under the bracken, and where, the local men told us, there had once been a Roman posting station, though nobody now living had ever found more of it than a few dressed stones ploughed up at the field edge.
It was Prosser who found the first of it, in a dry season when the beck had shrunk back and left a cutting bared that no one had troubled to look at in living memory. We went up together the next Sunday, out of nothing more than idleness and curiosity, and found, where the bank had slipped, the corner of a tessellated floor, most of it still whole beneath a foot of turf, the pattern in it — a running key-border round a central medallion, the colours as clean as the day they were laid — more perfect than anything either of us had ever seen, even in a picture-book.
We told no one at first. We went back with spades of our own, on Sundays, and worked at it through that winter and into the spring, uncovering by degrees not merely the floor but the footings of a whole villa beneath it, and beyond the villa, further up the hillside where the old road had run, the foundations of what must once have been a considerable settlement — granaries, a bath-house with its hypocaust still standing to a man’s height in places, and, cut into the turf where a slip had opened the ground, a small stone shrine with an altar still in place, its inscription weathered but legible if you knew how to coax the light across it at evening.
I cannot properly describe what it was to stand in that shrine at dusk, the first evening we cleared it, and read a name cut there by a man who had died some fifteen hundred years before either of us was born, and to know that no one living had read it before me. It went to my head a little, that knowledge, the way strong drink goes to the head of a man unused to it. I had never been much of a one for religion, chapel-bred as I was and indifferent even to that; but I understood, standing in that small roofless room with the light going, why a man might once have thought a place could hold something of what had been said and done in it, long after the doing was over.
We agreed, Prosser and I, that we would say nothing to the company, whose interest was in coal and nothing else, and who would as soon have driven a shaft through the villa floor as round it if it lay in their way. We went on working it quietly through that year, on our own time, telling ourselves we would find the right people to bring it to when we had uncovered enough to make the case properly — and it was in that same year, on the strength of what little Latin I had picked up from a curate who took an interest in me, and a good deal of importunate letter-writing on my own account, that I came to Aldous Furnival's notice, and was got, somehow, the funds and the coaching to sit the entrance examination that took me up to his college the following autumn.
I did not tell him, that first year, about the villa. I am not sure, now, why I kept it back so long — whether from some instinct that it was not yet mine to give away, or only the plain awkwardness of a farrier’s son who had not yet learned how much of himself he was permitted to say aloud in such company. Whatever the reason, it was two years before I told him, and by then Prosser and I had already begun to plan, in the letters that passed between us, what we would do with the site once my studies allowed me time to come back to it properly — and it was that plan, and what came of it, that I am now going to set down, as plainly as I can, because it is the part of the story Dr. Furnival never rightly had from me while I lived, and because I think, on the whole, he is owed it now.
Chapter II
I went up to London in the long vacation of my second year, with a box of the smaller finds packed in straw — some coin, a fine bronze fibula, a handful of samian ware — and the best of our photographs, taken with a borrowed camera that did the place no justice at all, making a fine Roman bath-house look no better than a heap of field-clearance stones.
I had a letter from our own Member, got through a schoolmaster who remembered me, and he was cordial enough but sent me wrong from the first, insisting I apply to the Office of Works, since the site, strictly, might be held to fall under ancient monuments legislation. The Office of Works kept me waiting the better part of a week, and when I was seen at last, a tired, kindly man told me his department’s business was with monuments already scheduled, not with new discoveries, and that I wanted the Society of Antiquaries, or failing them, the British Museum.
I went from one to the other through most of that August, packed off each time with fresh introductions and no nearer my object. I sat a great deal in waiting-rooms, watching secretaries hurry past with their hats already on, on their way to luncheon, which seemed to be the one appointment in London that nobody ever missed. The clerks found me diverting, I think, in the way a green boy from the country is generally found diverting by people who have long since stopped being surprised by anything.
It was a young woman in the Museum’s outer office, a Miss Trevelyan, who first took a real interest in me, and told me plainly what nobody else had troubled to say: that the men I wanted to see were besieged all day by people wanting favours, and suspicious of anyone who hadn’t the sense to ask for their time properly.
“You must invite him to luncheon,” she said. “Somewhere he wouldn’t think of paying for himself. It will cost you more than you like, but it will get you further than a month of sitting in that chair.”
I did as she advised, and got my interview at last with a Mr. Edric Winnall, the keeper of the relevant department, over a lunch that cost me nearly a fortnight’s wages and taught me a good deal more about his decorations from an Exhibition tour of Vienna than about anything I’d come to ask him. But at the end of it he agreed to see the site himself, or send someone qualified to see it, once the funds could be found — and there, for the whole of that summer, the matter stuck. There was a Parliamentary grant under discussion, he told me, but the Museum’s own governors had their attention chiefly fixed on an International Exhibition the following year, at which several of them hoped for appointments that would carry them abroad at the public expense, and it was plain enough, before the summer was out, which of the two causes had the greater claim on their energies.
Miss Trevelyan was honestly sorry for me, and said as much, more than once, over the modest teas I could still afford once the luncheon had eaten so deep into my savings. “They don’t care tuppence for your Romans,” she told me plainly. “What they care about is Paris, and another ribbon on the coat.”
I left London in September with nothing accomplished but the loss of most of what I had saved, and wrote to Prosser from the train that I’d had no luck and didn’t know when I’d have money enough to come back and try again properly. I told him to go on as we had planned, quietly, on our own account, until I could manage something better through the college itself — not knowing, as I wrote it, how very much better, and how very much worse, that patience of mine was about to be repaid.
Chapter III
I was three weeks getting home, want of money forcing me onto slow trains and once, for two days, onto my own two feet; and I came into Knighton at dusk on a Friday, tired through, meaning to walk the last six miles up the valley that same night rather than spend a shilling I hadn’t got on a bed.
I went first to the carrier's yard to ask after Prosser, since Ivor Rhys had done all our hauling and generally knew where a man stood before the man knew it himself.
“You've not heard, then,” Rhys said, and I could tell from his face, before he said another word, that I was not going to like what came next. “There's been a German gentleman up the valley, name of Vogt. Buying. Your Mr. Prosser's sold him the lot — the floor mosaics, the altar stone, every pot and pin of it, packed out on my own mules over a fortnight, and paid four hundred pound down for the privilege.”
I asked him, I believe, three separate times to say it again, as though a fourth hearing might change the sense of it.
“He's not been ungenerous with anybody, mind. Paid me handsome for the carting. But there's ill feeling in the village all the same — folk saying the place belonged to nobody more than to anybody, and no more right in Prosser to sell it than in the parson.”
I walked up the valley that night without stopping, and got to the hut an hour before dawn. Prosser was there before me, sitting up with a lamp, as though he'd known I must come sometime and had rather face it awake than be woken to it.
“Don't rip me up before you've heard it, Tom — I mean, Anthony,” he began, catching himself on the name in the old way, from the years before I went up to college. “There wasn't time to write and wait for an answer. Vogt was leaving the district in a week and wouldn't come back.”
“You might have wired me. You knew where I was.”
“And told you what — that I'd a buyer at four hundred pound, and would you kindly telegraph your blessing by return? You'd have wired back to wait, and we'd have lost him, same as we lost the Museum for want of waiting a year already.”
“We hadn't lost the Museum. We'd only not yet won it.”
“Four years you've been not yet winning it,” he said, not unkindly, but with a weariness that told me this argument had been rehearsed alone, more than once, before I ever arrived to hear it. “I've a family coming, Anthony — I'm to be married at Michaelmas, which I don't believe I've had the chance to tell you, what with everything. Four hundred pound is four hundred pound. Who else was ever going to pay real money for a heap of old stone?”
I did not, for some time, trust myself to answer him at all. When I did, I told him as plainly as I could that the question of selling had simply never entered my mind — that I had thought of the site as a thing found, not a thing owned; that it belonged, if it belonged to anyone living, to the valley and the country that had kept it hidden and to no particular man's pocket, mine least of all.
“I never knew you thought different from that,” he said. “I thought you cared for it the way a man cares for a good vein of coal he's found — proud of the finding, and glad enough of what it brings.”
“If Winnall himself had come to me and offered four thousand instead of four hundred, I'd have told him the same as I'm telling you. There was never a question of money in it, for me. I'd have sold my own name before I sold that shrine.”
He had no answer to that beyond the one he'd already given, and after a while he stopped trying to give it, and only sat with his head down, turning his cap in his hands.
“There's your share of it banked in your name,” he said at last. “A hundred and eighty pound. I split it fair.”
“I won't touch it,” I told him. “Not now, and not later, however I'm placed for money, and I'd be obliged if you'd understand that I mean it as I say it, and not as a manner of speaking.”
I meant to do more than refuse it quietly, though. Two days after, sick as it made me to do it, I wrote to Winnall myself and told him plainly what had happened — that the site he had been too slow to fund had been sold whole to a private foreign buyer through no fault but the Museum's own delay, and that if there was any way of recovering the material for the nation, however late, I would give whatever testimony was wanted to help it, regardless of what it cost Prosser or, for that matter, myself. It cost me the whole of the valley's good opinion when the letter's substance got back there, as such things always do; I was called, by men who had known me from a boy, an informer and worse, and it was two years and more before I could go back to that country and be spoken to civilly. It cost Prosser the sale price too, in the end, in fines and legal trouble the letter set in motion, though none of it brought so much as a shard of the mosaic back across the Channel.
I have never been sorry for the letter, whatever it cost either of us. I am sorry, and shall always be sorry, that it was Prosser who taught me what a valley full of neighbours thinks of a man who won't let a wrong stand merely because standing against it costs more than staying quiet.
Chapter IV
Prosser was married at Michaelmas as he'd said, and I did not go to the wedding, though I heard of it. We did not speak again for the better part of three years, and when at last we did — by chance, at a market in Knighton, both of us older and neither of us, I think, quite so certain of our own righteousness as we had been that night in the hut — it was a civil enough exchange, but there was no going back of it to what we had been. Some distances, once opened, don't close, whatever goodwill is brought to bear on either side of them.
The site itself went on being talked of in the district for years after, generally to my disadvantage, though there were always one or two, Ivor Rhys chief among them, who held that a man was right to make a noise about a wrong even at his own expense, and who went on being friendly to me for it. I never went back to it as often as I meant to. It is a hard thing to stand in a place you once thought belonged to no one and had by then to think of as merely lost, the actual stones scattered God knew where among German museum cases and private cabinets, the shrine's inscription probably catalogued now under some collector's own name rather than the name of the man who cut it.
Dr. Furnival never asked me, in all the years I knew him afterward, to say more of it than I had already told him piecemeal, in the version I have set down here more fully than I ever managed aloud. I think he understood, without my having to say so, that it was not a story I could easily tell twice in the same words, and that the telling of it once, honestly, was as much as I had in me to give.
What I will say, because it is the one thing I am certain of, looking back on it now from a greater distance than I had then: I have never for one hour regretted the letter to Winnall, whatever it cost me in that valley, and whatever it cost Prosser, who was not by any full accounting a bad man, only a man who had never been taught, as I somehow had, that a thing can be real and binding on a man's conduct without ever once turning a profit for him. I do not know where I learned that, unless it was standing in that shrine at dusk the first evening, reading a dead man's name by the last of the light, and understanding for the first time that some things are owed regardless of who is watching to see whether the debt gets paid.
[End of Merefield’s Account]
Book Three — The Professor
Chapter I
All that summer, while he sent Cordelia and the Ancrofts cheerful accounts of his industry in France, Furnival was doing, in truth, very little.
He had begun, in a desultory way, annotating the field notebooks Merefield had kept during that long-ago season on the border, and had come, somewhere in the slow work of it, upon the fuller written account — the one set down here in the boy's own words, found among his papers after Loos, addressed to no one in particular and evidently meant, someday, for Furnival himself, though it had never been sent.
Reading it that summer, alone in the old house, Furnival understood for the first time the full shape of a story he had only ever had before in fragments — Anthony's old reticence about a valley in the border country, a partnership gone wrong, a letter written at real cost. He had known there was a wound somewhere behind the boy's occasional silences. He had not known its size, nor its price, nor that Anthony had paid that price alone and never once complained of it.
It was, Furnival thought, turning the pages by lamplight, a stranger and better inheritance than any patent or fortune — the plain fact, set down in a dead boy's own hand, that a man could choose to pay for the truth of a thing rather than let it stand unpaid for, and count the payment, on the whole, well made.
Chapter II
By the first of August, Furnival realised he had trifled away the better part of two months on a task that should have taken a fortnight. But he had been doing a good deal else besides, something he had not, in all his years, quite managed before.
He had always been a little contemptuous of men who spoke of “losing themselves” in reverie, just as he was contemptuous of men who confessed, as though it were an achievement, to having “an imagination.” His own mind had always gone about its business in a plain, working fashion; when it was not occupied, it slept. He had no twilight state between the two. But that summer he found he could lie an hour together on the old couch, doing nothing that could be called thought and nothing that could be called rest either, and come out of it each time with the odd, persistent sense that he had been in company with someone — not Anthony, who did not come back to him that way, however often he had half hoped it, reading the notebooks — but another boy altogether: the one he had been, long before Paris, long before Cordelia, on a smallholding above the Wye where his father had kept a few sheep and taught school three days a week to make the rents.
He did not, examining the sensation as carefully as he examined anything, mistake it for what it was not. He was not dissolving into that boy, nor into the hills the boy had known, nor into any general continuity of earth and season such as a man might read of in a poem and take, sentimentally, for a philosophy. What came back to him, rather, with a clarity that startled him, was the recognition that it was the same mind at work now as then — the identical rational faculty, weighing and judging, that had once decided, at eleven years old, that a shepherd's arithmetic for reckoning a flock was wrong, and had gone quietly and worked out the correct method for himself before ever mentioning the error to his father. The boy on the hillside had reasoned as plainly, and as much for the pleasure of reasoning correctly, as the man now writing history reasoned; the difference between them was not of kind but of furniture — the later man had acquired a wife, a chair, a reputation, and forty years of accumulated obligation, none of which had been present to trouble the boy's clear thinking, and none of which, he now saw, had ever actually been necessary to it.
This was not, he understood, a discovery that the scholar was an accident and the boy the only reality, as he might carelessly have put it to himself in a weaker hour. It was rather the discovery that the judging self — the thing in him capable of assenting to a true proposition and withholding assent from a false one — had never depended for its existence on the wife, the chair, or the reputation at all, and could be recovered, whole and undiminished, simply by setting the furniture temporarily aside and attending to what remained. What remained was not less than a man. It was, if anything, more nearly the man himself than the fully furnished version had ever been.
He thought of his grandfather, old Emrys Furnival, who had gone about in his last years wrapped in a silence the family took for failing wits, and whom Furnival now suspected of having arrived, by his own slower road, at the same recognition — not a man losing his faculties, but a man quietly auditing which of his furnishings a rational agent actually required, and finding the honest answer to be: fewer than he had spent a lifetime accumulating.
What troubled him, once he had sat with the recognition a while, was a further thought that followed hard upon it, and would not be reasoned away as easily as the first had been reasoned toward. If the judging self did not depend upon the furniture of a life for its existence, then neither, properly examined, did that self's excuses depend upon it. A man could no longer tell himself that circumstance had used him ill, or that grief, or fatigue, or the erosion of ordinary years, had worn down some faculty that had once been more robust. The faculty was intact. It had always been intact. Whatever came next, in whatever state his health or his fortunes left him, would be a matter of what he chose to assent to with that same undiminished faculty — not a matter of what remained of him after subtraction, but a matter of what he, the same rational agent who had corrected a shepherd's arithmetic at eleven, decided to do.
It was not, on the whole, a comfortable thought to have arrived at, alone, in a cold little room, at fifty-three. But he found, turning it over through the last warm evenings of that August, that he did not wish to un-think it.
Chapter III
At midnight Furnival was lying on the box-couch in the old study, wrapped in blankets, a hot-water bottle at his feet grown cold some while since; and Mercy Coles was there in the room with him, sitting in her old sewing-chair by the lamp, a shawl about her shoulders, reading her worn little book of devotions. When he stirred she came over at once.
“Are you easy, Doctor?”
“Very, thank you. When did you come in, Mercy?”
“Not any too soon, sir,” she said, with a touch of reproof she could not quite keep out of her voice. “That old stove of yours had been up to its tricks again. I smelled the gas from the hall, and I heard you fall.”
“I remember the falling,” he said slowly. “I remember a good deal, in fact, that I hadn’t expected to remember.”
What he remembered, though he did not at once try to put it into words for her, was this: waking in the chair with the room already thick and his head swimming, and understanding, with a clarity that had nothing dreamlike about it, exactly what was happening to him and exactly what was required — the window, six feet off, already latched half shut against the night air. He remembered thinking, quite distinctly, of the recognition that had come to him in August: that the faculty which must now decide whether to get up or to let the swimming darkness have its way was the same faculty, undiminished, that had once corrected a shepherd's arithmetic on a hillside, and owed no excuse to fatigue or grief or the accumulated weight of a difficult year, because none of those things had ever actually touched what it was. He remembered choosing, quite deliberately, to get up. He remembered the chair overturning, and the floor coming up harder than he expected, and after that very little, until Mercy's voice.
“You were near the door when I found you,” she said. “Not on the couch at all. I couldn’t think how you’d got so far, weak as you must have been by then.”
“I got up on purpose, Mercy. I want that understood, though I don’t know that it much matters to you how I got there, so long as I did.”
She looked at him a moment as though the distinction struck her as a strange one for a man to insist upon at midnight, half recovered from being nearly gassed; but she only said, “Well, you're here to say so, which is the main thing,” and went back to her book, and let him lie thinking in the lamplight.
He did think, a good while, turning the night's accounting over as a man turns over a ledger he has some reason to distrust. He had been low in spirits the whole summer — he would not deny that to Dr. Pargeter in the morning, when the man came to look him over. But he had not been careless of his own life, whatever Cordelia might fear when she heard of it; he had not let the darkness take him without a contest, the way he suspected, uncomfortably, that some quieter and more thoroughgoing version of himself might once have done, in the very same room, on some other night, if the recognition of August had never come to him at all. The recognition had not saved him by magic. It had done something smaller and, he thought, more honest than that: it had left him no excuse, when the moment came, for not getting up.
He did not, on reflection, feel that he owed his family a great deal, examined honestly. Cordelia had had the best thirty years of his life, and joyful years they had been, and nothing could take that from either of them; but they were spent, and his daughters had grown past any real need of him, each in her own direction. What he did feel, turning toward Mercy Coles in her sewing-chair, upright and plain and entirely unsentimental about the whole affair, was something nearer obligation than he generally allowed himself to feel toward anyone — and he found, turning that feeling over as carefully as he had turned over everything else that night, that it was real, and that admitting a thing to be real was, at his age, very nearly enough.
“I should like you to stay till morning, if you would, Mercy,” he said. “Not from any weakness — I find I’m stronger than I’ve any right to expect. Only for the company of it.”
“Very well, sir,” she said, and turned her page, and the lamp burned on, and outside the small square window the last of the storm went quietly out over the park toward morning.
Chapter IV
Cordelia and the Ancrofts came home in September, brown from the Mediterranean sun and full of a summer's small news, and found the Professor thinner than they had left him, and told by Dr. Pargeter to rest more and smoke less, and otherwise, as far as any of them could see, entirely himself.
He did not tell them of the night with the stove beyond what Mercy Coles had already let slip to the housemaid, and what the housemaid had inevitably carried further. Cordelia was frightened when she heard of it, and reproached him, gently, for the old habit of the open window and the unmended stove, and he let her reproach him, and did not trouble to explain to her the distinction he had been so insistent upon with Mercy in the small hours — that he had not merely survived the night, but had met it.
He gave the finished notebooks to Rosalind's own publisher that autumn, with Anthony's fuller written account bound in as an appendix, over Cordelia's mild objection that it made for strange reading, a scholar's careful notes on Roman drainage followed by a young man's confession of a broken partnership in the same border hills. Furnival held that the two belonged together, and would not be argued out of it: the notebooks showed what Anthony had found, and the account showed what he had been willing to pay to keep faith with the finding, and a man's work, properly understood, was never separable from what he had been willing to pay for it.
Honor came to him one evening in October, in the old study — he had kept it on through the autumn, on no better pretext than that he liked it — and found him at the propped table with the finished proofs before him.
“You look well, Papa. Better than in the summer, Mother says.”
“I am well, Honor. Better than I have any strict right to be, perhaps, but I find I don't propose to argue with good fortune when it comes uninvited.”
She picked up the proofs and turned to the appendix, and read a page or two in silence, her eyes going, once, to the old travelling-rug still folded at the foot of the couch.
“He'd have liked knowing you kept faith with it,” she said at last. “The whole of it — not just the notebooks, the letter too. I think that's what he'd have minded most, if anyone had ever let the letter be forgotten.”
“I don't propose to let it be forgotten,” Furnival said. “Whatever else grows dim, I find that particular resolution has grown a good deal clearer to me this year than it ever was before, and I mean to hold to it while I've the wit left to hold to anything.”
He walked her down to the gate himself, in the last of the light, and stood a while after she had gone, looking back at the small lit window under the roof where he had spent, by his own rough reckoning, the greater part of a working life — and found, standing there, that he was neither afraid of what remained of that life nor indifferent to it, but only, for the first time in some years, entirely present to it: a man, in full possession of the one faculty that had never actually left him, deciding, quite deliberately, what to do next.
[End]
Theoretical foundations: Grant C. Sterling (Eastern Illinois University). Analysis and synthesis: Dave Kelly. Prose rendering: Claude (Anthropic). 2026.
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home