The Heart and Soul of Stoicism and Enchiridion 1--5

The Heart and Soul of Stoicism and Enchiridion 1--5

"Only internal things (e.4) are in my control (e.1). Unhappiness is caused by (falsely) believing (e.5) that externals are good or evil, which causes us to desire the world to be one way rather than another, which inevitably causes unhappiness when the world doesn't conform (e.2). If I eliminate my belief that externals are ever bad, I can even prevent all grief when my child or wife dies, or when I myself face death" (e.3)" (Grant C. Sterl8ng w/o Enchiridion referrences).

Support the propositions in the text with Enchiriridion referrences above, with the ideas in the corresponding Enchiridion chapters below.

Claude:

Let me analyze how each labeled proposition (e.1-e.5) in the text corresponds to specific ideas in the Enchiridion chapters: 

e.1: "Only internal things are in my control"

- This directly aligns with Chapter 1's opening statement: "Of things some are in our power, and others are not." The chapter explicitly lists what's in our power (opinion, movement, desire, aversion) and what isn't (body, property, reputation, offices). 

e.2: "which inevitably causes unhappiness when the world doesn't conform"

- This corresponds to Chapter 2's statement: "he who fails in his desire is unfortunate; and he who falls into that which he would avoid, is unhappy." The chapter explains that trying to avoid things not in our power (like disease or death) leads to unhappiness. 

e.3: "If I eliminate my belief that externals are ever bad, I can even prevent all grief when my child or wife dies, or when I myself face death"

- This matches Chapter 3's teaching about remembering the true nature of things we love: "If you are kissing your child or wife, say that it is a human being whom you are kissing, for when the wife or child dies, you will not be disturbed." 

e.4: "Only internal things"

- This connects to Chapter 4's emphasis on maintaining our will "in a manner conformable to nature" regardless of external circumstances. The chapter demonstrates how to focus on our internal response rather than external events. 

e.5: "(falsely) believing"

- This aligns with Chapter 5's central thesis: "Men are disturbed not by the things which happen, but by the opinions about the things." The chapter explicitly states that our beliefs/opinions about things, not the things themselves, cause our disturbance. 

The text accurately synthesizes key Stoic principles from these chapters, particularly the distinction between internal and external things, and the role of beliefs in causing unhappiness. 

Chapter 1. Of things some are in our power, and others are not. In our power are opinion, movement toward a thing, desire, aversion (turning from a thing); and in a word, whatever are our own acts: not in our power are the body, property, reputation, offices (magisterial power), and in a word, whatever are not our own acts. And the things in our power are by nature free, not subject to restraint nor hindrance: but the things not in our power are weak, slavish, subject to restraint, in the control of others. Remember then that if you think the things which are by nature slavish to be free, and the things which are in the power of others to be your own, you will be hindered, you will lament, you will be disturbed, you will blame both gods and men: but if you think that only which is your own to be your own, and if you think that what is another's, as it really is, belongs to another, no man will ever compel you, no man will hinder you, you will never blame any man, you will accuse no man, you will do nothing involuntarily (against your will), no man will harm you, you will have no enemy, for you will not suffer any harm. 

If then you desire (aim at) such great things, remember that you must not (attempt to) lay hold of them with a small effort; but you must leave alone some things entirely, and postpone others for the present. But if you wish these things also (such great things), and power (office) and wealth, perhaps you will not gain even these very things (power and wealth) because you aim also at those former things (such great things): certainly you will fail in those things through which alone happiness and freedom are secured. Straightway then practice saying to every harsh appearance, You are an appearance, and in no manner what you appear to be. Then examine it by the rules which you possess, and by this first and chiefly, whether it relates to the things which are in our

power or to the things which are not in our power: and if it relates to anything which is not in our power, be ready to say, that it does not concern you.

Chapter 2. Remember that desire contains in it the profession (hope) of obtaining that which you desire; and the profession (hope) in aversion (turning from a thing) is that you will not fall into that which you attempt to avoid: and he who fails in his desire is unfortunate; and he who falls into that which he would avoid, is unhappy. If then you attempt to avoid only the things contrary to nature which are within your power, you will not be involved in any of the things which you would avoid. But if you attempt to avoid disease or death or poverty, you will be unhappy. Take away then aversion from all things which are not in our power, and transfer it to the things contrary to nature which are in our power. But destroy desire completely for the present. For if you desire anything which is not in our power, you must be unfortunate: but of the things in our power, and which it would be good to desire, nothing yet is before you. But employ only the power of moving toward an object and retiring from it; and these powers indeed only slightly and with exceptions and with remission. 

Chapter 3. In everything which pleases the soul, or supplies a want, or is loved, remember to add this to the (description, notion); what is the nature of each thing, beginning from the smallest? If you love an earthen vessel, say it is an earthen vessel which you love; for when it has been broken, you will not be disturbed. If you are kissing your child or wife, say that it is a human being whom you are kissing, for when the wife or child dies, you will not be disturbed.

Chapter 4. When you are going to take in hand any act, remind yourself what kind of an act it is. If you are going to bathe, place before yourself what happens in the bath: some splashing the water, others pushing against one another, others abusing one another, and some stealing; and thus with more safety you will undertake the matter, if you say to yourself, I now intend to bathe, and to maintain my will in a manner conformable to nature. And so you will do in every act: for thus if any hindrance to bathing shall happen, let this thought be ready; it was not this only that I intended, but I intended also to maintain my will in a way conformable to nature; but I shall not maintain it so, if I am vexed at what happens.

Chapter 5. Men are disturbed not by the things which happen, but by the opinions about the things: for example, death is nothing terrible, for if it were, it would have seemed so to Socrates; for the opinion about death, that it is terrible, is the terrible thing. When then we are impeded or disturbed or grieved, let us never blame others, but ourselves, that is, our opinions. It is the act of an ill-instructed man to blame others for his own bad condition; it is the act of one who has begun to be instructed, to lay the blame on himself; and of one whose instruction is completed, neither to blame another, nor himself.